Baton passed from ACT-I to ACT-X
@MasatakaGoto: "Baton passed from ACT-I to ACT-X" (Masataka Goto), a PDF of the article in the Journal of the VR Society of Japan URL! (5 pages, free of charge) This is based on my experience as a research director of JST ACT-I "Information and the Future" until last year and as a current advisor for ACT-X "Frontiers of Mathematics and Information". https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F2lJEvraYAI6jJd.jpg
Dr. Yuichiro Anzai, "Let's establish the individual." Advice: "Be free to think independently, promote your own research, and become a leading expert in your field.
The ACT-I was designed with the aim of supporting young researchers with "passion," with an emphasis on helping them to "establish themselves.
Following the success of ACT-I, its successor program, JST ACT-X, continues to develop as "a program that hopes to establish individual young researchers
1 ) Supporting young researchers to "establish themselves
(2) Support young researchers to promote challenging research and development while taking the initiative with free ideas.
Introduced "an immediate and confidential communication environment through text chat tools" to the interview screening process.
Text communication in Slack
Communication between the research director, area advisors, and JST staff on their own computers
Not visible to applicants.
Exchange opinions during presentations and during questioning.
Share what opinions and questions you had while listening to the interview presentation.
Able to traffic what the research director wants the area advisor to hear in the Q&A session.
Slack implementation has been dramatically superior
Screening of a large number of applicants and diverse disciplines made possible based on in-depth discussions
Impossible to just use the usual method of filling out the evaluation sheet after the presentation and sharing that file.
In ACT-I, the standard period of support was set at 1.5 years, and an additional accelerated phase period of 2 years was set for about one-third of the standard period by JST.
We thought it was important to avoid the stage-gate-like misconception that "only the successful ones will advance to the acceleration phase." Explicit notice that the standard period is the heart of ACT-I's support
All young researchers who took on the challenge of a year and a half of research can be proud to be "graduates" of this research area and be able to play an active role thereafter. An important concept for unexplored juniors and unexplored ITnishio.icon
We need to make sure that those who were not selected as Super Creators can be proud to be "graduates".
We must ensure that those who did not advance to the Unexplored Advanced are not regarded as "those who could not lead to commercialization".
Additional support was made available on request.
In fact, many do not wish to.
3 .Act-I "Information and the Future" area meeting devised by
A place for friendly competition and mutual inspiration
Foundation for future collaboration
be memorable
It is important to provide opportunities for human interaction
It is difficult for about 70 people to interact with each other in a friendly and memorable way by simply repeating 70 short presentations and Q&A sessions, as is typical at academic conferences.
(i) Creating an active voice environment through text chat
When you have a simple question about the content of a presentation that is far away from your area of expertise, it is less psychologically challenging to post it in a chat room.
Other audience members with close expertise provided supplementary explanations, which deepened the understanding of the audience as a whole.
Gives more feedback than the usual questioning
Visualize what a large audience thought of your presentation
Slack content displayed on a small screen in front so that it could be read
(ii) Use of large, easy-to-read name tags
Postcard-sized nameplate with last name in a large, prominent font
Print the same information on both sides of the nameplate so that the first and last name can be read even if the nameplate is turned over.
Also include the title of the research project
The color of the nameplate was changed for each fiscal year so that students could easily identify their peers.
(iii) Seat assignment
To make it easier to talk to people you have never talked to before and to promote interdisciplinary exchange
All seating in the presentation rooms and at lunch and dinner were reserved.
Once you talk next to each other, it will be easier to talk during breaks, etc.
Reflection with KPT
All participants reflect on the domain meeting and write a 5-minute summary in Slack at the end of each meeting.
An average of about 149 entries are written.
Area Advisor Talks and Research Summary Talks: 5-minute talks per person when time permits on the program.
Content is left up to the speaker
Alumni Session
Researchers (graduates) who have completed their research term may voluntarily participate in area meetings upon agreeing to a confidentiality agreement.
After 2020, when the number of presenters will be reduced, we will have time for alumni to report on their recent activities.
is "voluntary" meaning "available to those who wish to participate"?
If that's the case, then the route is a little different from the unexplored IT that "participates at the request of the PM"
In the fifth year (2006) after this trial began, Unexplored said, "By all means, come on over in droves!"
Since 2008, there have been so many people who wanted to participate that the time for alumni to report on their recent activities has been overflowing.
After that, they stopped taking requests to participate.
The four regional meetings after FY2020 will be held using Zoom.
The audience always showed up, too, and we made an effort to clearly state the family name and the year of adoption.
The ability to see each other's faces during breaks and other times of the day made it possible to interact in a chat-like manner.
get-together
Zoom's Breakout Room
Random forced shuffling every 15 minutes
Advantages for alumni to participate remotely
There are many difficulties regarding which is better compared to the physical holding.nishio.icon
Definitely useful as a work-around for a time when it was not possible to hold a physical at COVID19
Ditto the benefit of facilitating alumni participation.
There is fatigue due to prolonged periods of constant frontal viewing.
There is a psychological hurdle to starting a conversation in a general shared setting during breaks.
When you go to the person you want to talk to in a physical holding and start talking, you start with a conversation between two people, and that conversation is visible to those around you, so people can gradually join in.
Zoom starts with a whole broadcast.
On the other hand, if you create a breakout room that can be freely entered and exited for individual conversation, the conversation in the room cannot be seen from the outside. I think this is the degree to which Zoom's UI could be improved in this area.
is not very good, and in 2021, the management allocated (rather than randomizing the system) to Zoom's breakout room
Close to [Reserved seat method
The 2022 Unexplored Conference Night was a get-together at oVice. I also have the impression that Remo and Gather.town are being tried here and there. 4 .Act-I "Information and the future" ingenuity in the debriefing session of the results of the
ACT-I Advanced Research Forum, a public forum for the presentation of results
A place that attracts attention in an atmosphere different from that of a regular conference presentation
It is important to provide "a place where people feel it is worth presenting.
Professionally staged and hosted stage
High-impact visual and musical effects when researchers take the stage
Opening and closing videos are shown at the beginning and at the end of the entire event.
Attractively designed pamphlets distributed at the event
The Unexplored Conference alumni LT may be pretty close in composition, although the number of slots is small.nishio.icon
I wish I could afford more, but it looks like I can't.
Archives are also important
Video recordings of the presentations and posters were made continuously available on the Internet for anyone to view.
I completely agree with "archiving is important too."nishio.icon
In addition, the videos of boost meetings and interim presentations are stored in the private Scrapbox, in addition to the publicly available "results reports.
Participants from the next and subsequent years can see "what last year's participants presented" and have the opportunity to learn about the project development process
---
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/ACT-IからACT-Xへ渡されたバトン using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I'm very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.